The Vault

The Vault
Discover a hidden trove of exquisite artifacts, one-of-a-kind jewelry pieces, and iconic pop culture memorabilia all of incredible quality and incredible prices. (Really, our workshop wouldn't have it any other way.) With new items and themes weekly, The Vault Collection is constantly evolving. You'll never know what treasures you might find! So keep an eye on the vault for gifts for special occasions, that special someone, and especially yourself. The Vault at Mystery Control...it’s the real deal.

55 products

  • Lillie Langtry as Cleopatra Art Nouveau Limoges Porcelain Brooch with Gold Ormolu Asp frameLillie Langtry as Cleopatra Art Nouveau Limoges Porcelain Brooch with Gold Ormolu Asp frame
    Lillie Langtry as Cleopatra Art Nouveau Limoges Porcelain Brooch with Gold Ormolu Asp frame

    Lillie Langtry as Cleopatra Art Nouveau Limoges Porcelain Brooch with Gold Ormolu Asp frame

    Lillie Langtry as Cleopatra Art Nouveau Limoge Painted Porcelein Brooch with Gold Ormolu Snake frame. Lillie Langtry, actress, socialite and arguably the first mass media supermodel...

    $1,250.00 USD
    $1,250.00 USD
  • Navajo Heavy Concho Belt Buckle in 925 SIlverNavajo Heavy Concho Belt Buckle in 925 SIlver
    Navajo Heavy Concho Belt Buckle in 925 SIlver

    Navajo Heavy Concho Belt Buckle in 925 SIlver

    Navajo Stamped Sterling Silver Concho Belt Buckle in 925 Silver. Early 20 Century.

    $225.00 USD
    $225.00 USD
  • Faceted Carnelian & 925 Silver Pendant NecklaceFaceted Carnelian & 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Faceted Carnelian & 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Indulge in luxury with our stunning and unusual 915 silver faceted large carnelian pendant, made in the 70s era in the Navajo Style and stamped with...

    $100.00 USD
    $100.00 USD
  • Halcyon Days Smithsonian Enamel Pill Box You're The Cats Whiskers Kitten Milk

    Halcyon Days Smithsonian Enamel Pill Box You're The Cats Whiskers Kitten Milk

    Halcyon Days Smithsonian Enamel Pill Box "You're The Cats Whiskers Kitten Milk". About Halcyon Days: "In a digital age where mass production is the norm, Halcyon...

    $69.00 USD
    $69.00 USD
  • Baltic Amber "Flora" 925 Silver Pendant NecklaceBaltic Amber "Flora" 925 Silver Pendant Necklace
    Baltic Amber "Flora" 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Baltic Amber "Flora" 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Peer into forests and fields from a bygone millennia with this beautiful Amber "Flora" Pendant. Tiny petals and leaves are visible, captured in amber. Plants in...

    $150.00 USD
    $150.00 USD
  • Victorian Horseshoe Amber "Spinner" Fob 925 Silver Pendant NecklaceVictorian Horseshoe Amber "Spinner" Fob 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Victorian Horseshoe Amber "Spinner" Fob 925 Silver Pendant Necklace

    Are you a Victorian equestrian aficionado? This Victorian Amber "Spinner" Fob in Sterling Silver is for you. Spinner fobs were very popular around the 1880s. Think...

    $110.00 USD
    $110.00 USD
  • 1940s Taxco Eagle Amethyst and 925 Silver Necklace1940s Taxco Eagle Amethyst and 925 Silver Necklace

    1940s Taxco Eagle Amethyst and 925 Silver Necklace

    This 1940s Taxco Eagle Amethyst and Sterling Silver Necklace is adorned with two large half moon cut amethysts on its outstretched wings. A necklace is also...

    $150.00 USD
    $150.00 USD
  • Gorham Vintage 925 Silver & Gold Plate Unicorn Pendant NecklaceGorham Vintage 925 Silver & Gold Plate Unicorn Pendant Necklace
    Gorham Vintage 925 Silver & Gold Plate Unicorn Pendant Necklace

    Gorham Vintage 925 Silver & Gold Plate Unicorn Pendant Necklace

    Be the unicorn with this Gorham Vintage 925 Sterling Silver & Gold Plate Unicorn Pendant from the late 1970s/ early 1980s. This pendant, with its unicorn...

    $85.00 USD
    $85.00 USD
  • Onyx & Marcasite Sterling Silver Pendant with Blackened Sterling Silver ChainOnyx & Marcasite Sterling Silver Pendant with Blackened Sterling Silver Chain

    Onyx & Marcasite Sterling Silver Pendant with Blackened Sterling Silver Chain

    This necklace, made of Sterling Silver and featuring black onyx and marcasite strung on a blackened sterling silver chain, appears to be from the Art Deco...

    $150.00 USD
    $150.00 USD
  • Scottish IONA 925 Silver Luckenbooth Sweetheart Brooch

    Scottish IONA 925 Silver Luckenbooth Sweetheart Brooch

    The Scottish IONA Sterling Silver Luckenbooth Sweetheart Brooch from the 1970s is a cherished symbol of love in Scotland, often given as a token of betrothal...

    $100.00 USD
    $100.00 USD
  • Celluloid Victorian Mourning Cross Pendant NecklaceCelluloid Victorian Mourning Cross Pendant Necklace

    Celluloid Victorian Mourning Cross Pendant Necklace

    This Celluloid Victorian Mourning Cross is in very good condition. This striking piece of Victoriana also comes with a Rhodium Plated 925 Silver 22" rope chain....

    $225.00 USD
    $225.00 USD
  • 925 Silver George Elgin "Pistol-Cutlass-Style" Money Clip925 Silver George Elgin "Pistol-Cutlass-Style" Money Clip
    925 Silver George Elgin "Pistol-Cutlass-Style" Money Clip

    925 Silver George Elgin "Pistol-Cutlass-Style" Money Clip

    ***Note: This is NOT a firearm*** Attention Military and Adventure History fans! Own a rare and fiercely historical 925 Sterling Silver money clip that delivers style,...

    $350.00 USD
    $350.00 USD
  • Ashley Pitman A.P. Kenya Maltese Cross with 1970s Gold Plate ChainAshley Pitman A.P. Kenya Maltese Cross with 1970s Gold Plate Chain

    Ashley Pitman A.P. Kenya Maltese Cross with 1970s Gold Plate Chain

    This Ashley Pitman "A.P. Kenya" Maltese Cross is made of White Horn, Onyx and Brass and Measures 2.25"x 2.5". We're including a Gold Plate 18" 1970s...

    $275.00 USD
    $275.00 USD
  • Athena Cufflinks in Gold Fill, Resin & Carved ShellAthena Cufflinks in Gold Fill, Resin & Carved Shell

    Athena Cufflinks in Gold Fill, Resin & Carved Shell

    These cameo-style Athena Cufflinks in Gold Fill, Resin & Carved Shell date from the mid 20th Century. Perfect for your next cruise around the Mediterranean or...

    $150.00 USD
    $150.00 USD
  • Ishtar & Gilgamesh Stamped Goddess Charm Necklace in Sterling SilverIshtar & Gilgamesh Stamped Goddess Charm Necklace in Sterling Silver
    Ishtar & Gilgamesh Stamped Goddess Charm Necklace in Sterling Silver

    Ishtar & Gilgamesh Stamped Goddess Charm Necklace in Sterling Silver

    This charm necklace is at least 100 years old and was created when the area was part of Persia. Stamped in Sterling Silver, we are told...

    $60.00 USD
    $60.00 USD
  • Amethyst Heart Charm in 925 Sterling Silver with 22" Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Franco ChainAmethyst Heart Charm in 925 Sterling Silver with 22" Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Franco Chain
    Amethyst Heart Charm in 925 Sterling Silver with 22" Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Franco Chain

    Amethyst Heart Charm in 925 Sterling Silver with 22" Rhodium Plated Sterling Silver Franco Chain

    This large Amethyst Heart Charm Is the perfect for anyone who wants to give a gift symbolizing love and happiness. Comes with 22" Rhodium Plated Sterling...

    $125.00 USD
    $125.00 USD
  • Puffed Anchor Mariner 30" Chain Rhodium Plated Sterling SIlver

    Puffed Anchor Mariner 30" Chain Rhodium Plated Sterling SIlver

    This 6mm Puffed  Anchor Mariner Chain Necklace Rhodium Plated Sterling SIlver is just the right blend of structural interest, shine and versatility. Wear it anywhere. 6MM...

    $100.00 USD
    $100.00 USD
  • Green Onyx and Sterling Silver NecklaceGreen Onyx and Sterling Silver Necklace

    Green Onyx and Sterling Silver Necklace

    This Vintage Green Onyx and Sterling Silver Necklace was likely produced in Taxco, Mexico in the 1940s. Maker's Mark is partially illegible. This style of green...

    $250.00 USD
    $250.00 USD
  • "Sleeping Beauty" 925 Sterling Silver and Marcasite Brooch

    "Sleeping Beauty" 925 Sterling Silver and Marcasite Brooch

    This 925 sterling silver "Sleeping Beauty" Brooch came into a collection in the early 1990s, where we found it. The figure seems to have a "Hamsa...

    $85.00 USD
    $85.00 USD
  • "White Rabbit" 925 Silver and Marcasite Lapel Pin/ Pendant Necklace"White Rabbit" 925 Silver and Marcasite Lapel Pin/ Pendant Necklace

    "White Rabbit" 925 Silver and Marcasite Lapel Pin/ Pendant Necklace

    This 925 sterling silver "White Rabbit" Brooch is charming and delightful. Like other parts of this collection, it sat under wraps since the early 70s and...

    $65.00 USD
    $65.00 USD
  • 925 Silver & Onyx Pendant Necklace925 Silver & Onyx Pendant Necklace
    925 Silver & Onyx Pendant Necklace

    925 Silver & Onyx Pendant Necklace

    This 925 Sterling Silver and Taxco, Mexico-style Onyx Pendant has an unusual patina, so we're showing it as is. It has a 925 Stamp on the...

    $75.00 USD
    $75.00 USD
  • 925 Silver Athena's Owl Pendant Necklace925 Silver Athena's Owl Pendant Necklace

    925 Silver Athena's Owl Pendant Necklace

    "And though she be little, she is fierce!" Meet Athena's Owl. This diminutive vintage 925 Sterling Silver Eurasian Owl pendant features a 925 stamp on the...

    $45.00 USD
    $45.00 USD
  • 925 Silver & Garnet Pendant Necklace925 Silver & Garnet Pendant Necklace
    925 Silver & Garnet Pendant Necklace

    925 Silver & Garnet Pendant Necklace

    This 925 Sterling Silver and Taxco Mexico Garnet Pendant features a signature style featuring a geometric style that was popular in the 1940s. It has a...

    $85.00 USD
    $85.00 USD
  • 925 Sterling Silver Citrine Pendant Necklace925 Sterling Silver Citrine Pendant Necklace

    925 Sterling Silver Citrine Pendant Necklace

    This 925 Sterling Silver and Citrine Pendant features a wonderful citrine gem. It's placed in a vintage 70's era Navajo-style design. We've matched this golden gem...

    $95.00 USD
    $95.00 USD